James Suckling: 95
The riper sensations of red-plum compote and cherry kernel here are nicely mixed in with subtler nuances of dried rose petals and Chinese spices. These follow through to a full body, laced with polished tannins and finely judged, fresh red fruit. Quite long on the finish. Drink from 2023.
Wine Spectator: 93
A tough customer, with big, burly tannins dominating any fruit at this stage. Nonetheless, this is not overly astringent, and may just need more time. Fresh and long on the finish. Best from 2024 through 2045. —B.S.
Vinous: 91
The 2015 Barolo Pajana is a soft, forward wine that shows the ripeness of the year in its soft contours and open-knit personality. Gentle crushed red berry and floral notes give the 2015 lovely early appeal. I would prefer to drink it over the next handful of years.