Wine Advocate: 91+pts
The 2012 Cabernet Sauvignon Artz Vineyard comes from Red Mountain and exhibits classic graphite, dried earth and ground herbs mixed with black raspberry and black cherry-like fruit. Full-bodied, rich, structured and balanced, this is another terrific wine that will have 15 years or more of overall longevity. All three of these 2012s from this estate are highly recommended. Jeb Dunnuck, Jun 2015
Vinous: 90pts
Bright ruby-red. Blackcurrant and mocha on the nose. Very sweet and lush, with inviting black fruits flavors given shape by thoroughly ripe tannins. Not a particularly elegant wine but seamless and inviting, finishing with lovely lingering sweetness, an attractive oakiness and no rough edges.
Stephen Tanzer, Nov 2015